What Are Criminal Appeals?

A criminal appeal is a legal proceeding in which a higher court reviews the decisions made by a trial court to determine whether legal errors occurred that affected the outcome of your case. Unlike a trial, an appeal does not involve new evidence or witness testimony. Instead, the appellate court examines the existing trial record — transcripts, motions, rulings, and exhibits — to decide whether the law was correctly applied.

If you were convicted of a crime in Massachusetts or New Hampshire, an appeal may be your best opportunity to have that conviction or sentence overturned. But appellate work demands a specific skillset: the ability to analyze a complex record, identify meritorious legal issues, and present them persuasively in writing. That is what I do.

My Approach to Criminal Appeals

Criminal appeals are the core of my practice. I spent years as a prosecutor, first handling felonies in New Hampshire, then managing complex fraud and white collar investigations at the Massachusetts Attorney General's Office. That experience taught me exactly how the prosecution builds its case, where the pressure points are, and where errors are most likely to occur.

Now, as a defense-side appellate attorney, I use that knowledge to deconstruct trial records and identify the issues that appellate courts care about. Every case begins with a thorough review of the entire trial record, followed by independent legal research. I do not take shortcuts, and I do not file boilerplate briefs. Each argument is built from the ground up, tailored to the specific facts and legal issues in your case.

The Appellate Process in Massachusetts

Understanding how the appellate process works is essential to making informed decisions about your case. Here is a general overview of the steps involved in a Massachusetts criminal appeal:

Notice of Appeal

The notice of appeal is due within 30 days after sentencing (or after the judgment or order you are appealing, if later). If you miss it, the trial court can extend the time by up to 30 days for excusable neglect, and the appellate court can allow a late notice for good cause, but not more than one year after the verdict or sentence, whichever is later. Do not count on either.

Record Assembly

The trial court clerk assembles the record, including the transcripts the appellant orders, and the appeal is docketed in the Appeals Court.

Record Appendix

The appellant prepares a record appendix containing the key documents the appellate court will need to review the issues raised.

Appellant's Brief

This is the most critical document in the appeal. The brief identifies the legal errors, explains why they require reversal, and supports each argument with citations to the record and legal authority.

Commonwealth's Brief

The prosecution files a response brief defending the conviction and arguing that any errors were harmless.

Reply Brief

The appellant may file a reply brief addressing new arguments raised by the Commonwealth.

Oral Argument

In some cases, the Appeals Court or Supreme Judicial Court will schedule oral argument, giving both sides the opportunity to present their positions and answer the judges' questions.

Decision

The court issues a written opinion affirming, reversing, or vacating the conviction or sentence. In some cases, the court may remand the case for a new trial or resentencing.

Types of Issues Raised on Appeal

Not every trial error warrants reversal. Appellate courts apply different standards of review depending on the type of issue raised. The most effective appeals focus on errors that are both legally significant and supported by the record. Common categories include:

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

Under both the Sixth Amendment and Article 12 of the Massachusetts Declaration of Rights, you are entitled to effective representation at trial. Massachusetts courts ask whether counsel's performance fell measurably below what might be expected from an ordinary fallible lawyer and, if so, whether it likely deprived you of an otherwise available, substantial ground of defense. Commonwealth v. Saferian, 366 Mass. 89, 96 (1974). If it did, you may have grounds for relief. Examples include failing to investigate key witnesses, failing to file critical pretrial motions, giving incorrect advice about plea consequences, or making catastrophic strategic errors.

Evidentiary Errors

Trial courts make evidentiary rulings throughout the course of a trial — deciding what evidence the jury can and cannot consider. If the court improperly admitted prejudicial evidence (such as prior bad acts or unreliable expert testimony) or improperly excluded evidence favorable to the defense, those rulings may be challenged on appeal.

Sentencing Errors

Even if the conviction itself is upheld, the sentence imposed may be subject to appellate review. Sentencing errors include imposing a sentence that exceeds the statutory maximum, relying on inaccurate information at sentencing, or imposing conditions that are not authorized by law. For a state prison sentence imposed in the Superior Court, the Appellate Division of the Superior Court can review the sentence itself (unless the sentence was mandatory), but the appeal must be filed within ten days after sentencing, and the Appellate Division can increase the sentence after giving you an opportunity to be heard. A motion to revise and revoke under Rule 29 must be filed within 60 days.

Constitutional Violations

Constitutional errors can arise at every stage of a criminal case. Common constitutional issues on appeal include unlawful searches and seizures under the Fourth Amendment, coerced confessions or Miranda violations under the Fifth Amendment, denial of the right to confront witnesses under the Sixth Amendment, and due process violations under the Fourteenth Amendment. Massachusetts courts also provide independent protections under the state constitution that sometimes exceed federal standards.

Insufficient Evidence

A conviction must be supported by evidence sufficient for a rational trier of fact to find each element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt. If the Commonwealth's evidence, viewed in the light most favorable to the prosecution, fails to meet this standard, the conviction cannot stand.

Direct Appeals vs. Post-Conviction Relief

It is important to understand the distinction between a direct appeal and post-conviction relief, as they serve different purposes and involve different procedures.

A direct appeal is filed after sentencing and challenges errors that occurred during the trial proceedings. It is based on the existing trial record and must be filed within the applicable deadline (typically 30 days in Massachusetts).

Post-conviction relief encompasses a range of procedures outside the direct appeal. The most common vehicle in Massachusetts is a motion for new trial under Rule 30(b) of the Massachusetts Rules of Criminal Procedure. It can be filed at any time, before, during or after the direct appeal, and it can raise issues that depend on facts outside the trial record. These include newly discovered evidence that was unavailable at the time of trial, ineffective assistance of trial counsel raised for the first time, ineffective assistance of appellate counsel, constitutional violations that require evidence outside the trial record, and changes in the law that apply retroactively. Because post-conviction proceedings allow the court to consider facts beyond the four corners of the trial record, they often provide the only meaningful path to relief when the basis for a claim was not apparent during the original proceedings.

I handle both direct appeals and post-conviction matters, and I can advise you on which pathway is most appropriate for your situation.

Motions for New Trial

A motion for new trial under Rule 30(b) is one of the most powerful tools available in Massachusetts criminal law. Unlike a direct appeal, a motion for new trial allows you to present new evidence and raise issues that go beyond the four corners of the trial record.

These motions are particularly valuable when the basis for relief involves facts that were not known at the time of trial — for example, recanting witnesses, forensic evidence that has been discredited, or evidence of prosecutorial misconduct that was not disclosed to the defense. They also provide the primary vehicle for raising ineffective assistance of counsel claims that require an evidentiary hearing.

I approach motions for new trial with the same rigor I bring to appellate briefs: thorough investigation, meticulous legal research, and persuasive written advocacy.

Why Choose Me for Your Appeal

Prosecution Experience

I know how the other side thinks because I spent years on that side. As a former felony prosecutor and Assistant Attorney General, I understand the strategies prosecutors use and where their cases are vulnerable. That perspective is invaluable when identifying the pressure points in a trial record and crafting arguments that resonate with appellate judges.

Dedicated Appellate Practice

Criminal appeals are not a sideline for me. This is my primary practice area, and I bring the specialized research, writing, and advocacy skills that appellate work demands. Appellate law requires a fundamentally different approach than trial work, and I have built my practice around that distinction.

Multi-Jurisdictional Admission

I am admitted to practice in Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts.

Thorough Case Review

Every appeal begins with a comprehensive review of the entire trial record. I do not rely on summaries or shortcuts. I read every transcript, every motion, and every ruling to identify the strongest issues for appeal.

Clear Communication

I keep my clients informed at every stage of the process and make sure they understand the legal issues, the timeline, and the realistic prospects for their appeal. I answer questions promptly.

Criminal Appeal Guides

GuideCovers
Appealing a Criminal Conviction in MassachusettsHow a direct appeal works
Three Categories of Jail CreditWhen credit for time served is owed
When the Commonwealth Appeals, It Pays Your LawyerMass. R. Crim. P. 15(d) fees
When the Translator Never TestifiesTranslated recordings and the Confrontation Clause
Commonwealth v. RobinsonAn unlawful exit order and consent to search

Criminal Appeals FAQ

How long do I have to file a criminal appeal in Massachusetts? +

In Massachusetts, you generally have 30 days from the date of sentencing to file a notice of appeal in a superior court case. For district court cases, the deadline is also 30 days. If you miss it, the trial court can extend the time by up to 30 days for excusable neglect, and the appellate court can allow a late notice for good cause, but not more than one year after the verdict or sentence, whichever is later. Do not count on either. Post-conviction remedies such as motions for new trial may also be available. Contact an appellate attorney as soon as possible after your conviction to preserve your rights.

What issues can be raised on a criminal appeal? +

Common issues raised on appeal include ineffective assistance of counsel, evidentiary errors (such as improperly admitted or excluded evidence), sentencing errors, constitutional violations (including Fourth Amendment search and seizure issues, Fifth Amendment self-incrimination violations, and Sixth Amendment right-to-counsel issues), prosecutorial misconduct, insufficient evidence to support the conviction, and improper jury instructions. The strongest appeals identify specific, preserved legal errors that affected the outcome of the trial.

What is the difference between a direct appeal and post-conviction relief? +

A direct appeal challenges errors in the trial record and must be filed within 30 days of sentencing. A motion for a new trial under Rule 30(b) can be filed at any time, before, during or after the direct appeal, and is the way to raise issues that depend on facts outside the trial record, such as newly discovered evidence or ineffective assistance of counsel. Each pathway has different procedural requirements and standards of review.

Can I appeal if I pleaded guilty? +

You can challenge it, but the route is different. A guilty plea can be challenged by a motion in the trial court to withdraw the plea, which the court treats as a motion for a new trial under Rule 30(b). If the judge denies it, that ruling can be appealed. A knowing and voluntary plea waives nonjurisdictional defects in the proceedings before the plea, so the motion focuses on the plea itself: whether it was knowing and voluntary, or whether your lawyer's advice about it was deficient, for example about immigration consequences. A sentence the law did not allow can be corrected under Rule 30(a), and a motion to revise and revoke a lawful sentence must be filed within 60 days under Rule 29.

How long does a criminal appeal take in Massachusetts? +

A typical appeal in the Massachusetts Appeals Court takes 12 to 18 months from filing the notice of appeal to a decision. Cases before the Supreme Judicial Court may take longer. The process involves ordering transcripts, assembling the record, briefing, and potentially oral argument. Motions for new trial at the trial court level can sometimes be resolved more quickly.

What does an appellate attorney do differently than a trial attorney? +

Appellate attorneys specialize in legal research, persuasive writing, and identifying legal errors in trial court proceedings. While trial attorneys focus on witness examination and jury persuasion, appellate attorneys analyze the trial record, draft detailed legal briefs, and present oral arguments to panels of judges. The skillset is fundamentally different — appellate work is research-intensive and writing-driven.

Challenging a Conviction or Sentence?

Time limits apply to criminal appeals. Submit the form for a confidential review of your situation. I respond within one business day.