Criminal Appeals

One Year or Eighteen Months? How Massachusetts Sentences Large Capacity Gun Charges

← Back to Blog

Massachusetts punishes carrying an ordinary handgun without a license with a mandatory minimum of 18 months. Possessing a large capacity firearm without a license, the more serious-sounding charge, can carry a minimum of one year. That gap is real, the Supreme Judicial Court has discussed it openly, and the courts have spent the last seven years working out how the large capacity statute's penalty provisions fit together. For anyone charged under both statutes for the same gun, the answer also turns on a 2013 decision about duplicative convictions.

The two statutes

General Laws c. 269, § 10(a) covers possessing a firearm without a license outside your home or business. The penalty is "imprisonment in the state prison for not less than two and one-half years nor more than five years, or for not less than 18 months nor more than two and one-half years in a jail or house of correction," and the sentence "shall not be reduced to less than 18 months, nor suspended."

Section 10(m) covers knowingly possessing a large capacity firearm or large capacity feeding device without a license to carry. Its penalty paragraph has three parts. It first says the offender "shall be punished by imprisonment in a state prison for not less than two and one-half years nor more than ten years." It then says an offender who holds a valid firearm identification card "shall not be subject to any mandatory minimum sentence." And it adds that "[t]he sentence imposed upon such person shall not be reduced to less than one year, nor suspended."

Read together, those three parts do not obviously agree. The Supreme Judicial Court called the statute "vexing" and agreed with earlier descriptions of it as "no grammatical paragon" and "confusing." Commonwealth v. Rodriguez, 482 Mass. 366, 368 (2019).

What the courts have held about § 10(m)

The minimum term. In Rodriguez, the Supreme Judicial Court concluded that, for a defendant without an FID card, the Legislature meant "a lower end of the sentencing range of from one to two and one-half years, with at least one year to serve, in State prison." 482 Mass. at 373. It answered the reported question by holding that such a defendant "lawfully may be sentenced to State prison for not less than one year nor more than two and one-half years." Id. at 374.

The maximum term. Rodriguez did not decide how low the top of the sentence could go. In at least two reported cases, judges then imposed sentences of one year to one year and one day. The Appeals Court held those sentences unlawful, concluding that "the maximum term of a sentence for a violation of § 10 (m) committed by a person without a valid FID card must be at least two and one-half years." Commonwealth v. DaSilva, 105 Mass. App. Ct. 732, 738 (2025). The Supreme Judicial Court agreed in Commonwealth v. Psikarakis, 497 Mass. 301, 302 (2026), declined the Commonwealth's request to overrule Rodriguez, id. at 307-308, and held that double jeopardy did not bar resentencing the defendant to a lawful term, id. at 309.

The result, for someone convicted under § 10(m) without an FID card, is a state prison sentence with a minimum term between one year and two and a half years, at least one year to serve, and a maximum term of at least two and a half years and no more than ten.

FID card holders. A valid FID card is not a defense to § 10(m), but it removes the mandatory minimum. In Rodriguez the court said a judge would have discretion "to sentence an FID-card-holding felon to a sentence ranging presumably from probation to no more than ten years in State prison." 482 Mass. at 368 n.1. Whether probation is actually available to an FID holder is not settled.

The 18-month problem

The Commonwealth argued in Rodriguez that a one-year minimum for a large capacity magazine, against 18 months for an ordinary firearm, was absurd. The court rejected the argument in a footnote worth reading in full:

"We note first that, when G. L. c. 269, § 10 (m), was enacted in 1998, the minimum sentence for possession of a firearm, G. L. c. 269, § 10 (a), was one year. Eight years later, G. L. c. 269, § 10 (a), was amended such that the mandatory minimum sentence changed from one year to eighteen months. St. 2006, c. 48, § 5. None of the other minimum sentences for firearms offenses was increased. This amendment to § 10 (a), however, cannot be used to inform as to the Legislature's intent in enacting § 10 (m) eight years earlier. Moreover, as possession of a feeding device alone cannot result in a shooting, a mandatory minimum sentence for a feeding device that would be almost twice the length of the minimum sentence for possession of a firearm also could appear anomalous."

482 Mass. at 373 n.10. The court added that a person with a firearm capable of accepting a large capacity magazine "could be charged separately for possession of that firearm, in addition to charges for possession of the feeding device," and concluded, "We discern no absurdity." Id.

So the gap is a product of history. Section 10(a) was raised to 18 months in 2006, and § 10(m) was not.

Charged under both statutes for the same gun

The practical question is what happens when one gun produces both charges. The answer depends on which kind of § 10(m) charge it is.

A large capacity firearm and § 10(a) for the same gun: duplicative. In Commonwealth v. Rivas, 466 Mass. 184 (2013), the defendant had a .22 caliber handgun whose magazine was "capable of holding twelve," so the gun "met the statutory definition of a large capacity firearm." Id. at 186. The Supreme Judicial Court held that his § 10(a) conviction "is a lesser included offense of his conviction under count 4," the § 10(m) count, "and thus counts 1 and 4 are duplicative." Id. at 188. One of the two convictions has to go.

Which one goes is a sentencing decision. The court held that "the decision as to which duplicative conviction to vacate is a discretionary one," id. at 190, because once the case reaches sentencing "the decision is, at its essence, a sentencing decision," id. at 190-191. A trial judge "could, in order to fashion the most appropriate sentence, properly vacate either conviction." Id. at 191-192. The court left open "whether vacating a conviction for an offense that both carries the higher penalty and has more elements would be an abuse of discretion." Id. at 192 n.11.

That is where the 18-month problem lands. When § 10(a) and a large capacity firearm count under § 10(m) rest on the same gun, they are not stacked. They are alternatives, and the sentencing judge decides which conviction survives: § 10(a), with its 18-month mandatory minimum that can be served in a house of correction, or § 10(m), with its one-year minimum to serve in state prison and a maximum of at least two and a half years.

A gun and a separate magazine: not duplicative. When the § 10(m) charge is for a large capacity feeding device rather than the gun itself, the analysis changes. The gun and the magazine are separate items, and each offense has an element the other lacks. Rodriguez itself noted that the gun and the feeding device "could be charged separately." 482 Mass. at 373 n.10. The Appeals Court has applied that reasoning to a firearm count and a feeding device count in several unpublished decisions, which may be cited for their persuasive value but are not binding precedent. See Commonwealth v. Hutchins, 102 Mass. App. Ct. 1110 (2023) (Rule 23.0 decision) (§ 10(h) firearm counts; neither offense is a lesser included offense of the other); Commonwealth v. Polizzotti, 99 Mass. App. Ct. 1105 (2021) (Rule 23.0 decision) (same, where the magazine was loaded in the gun); Commonwealth v. Jackson, 91 Mass. App. Ct. 1131 (2017) (Rule 1:28 decision); Commonwealth v. Ragland, 71 Mass. App. Ct. 1119 (2008) (Rule 1:28 decision).

What this means if you are charged

Read the § 10(m) count closely. If it charges the gun as a large capacity firearm, and there is also a § 10(a) count for the same gun, the two convictions cannot both stand, and the question of which one survives belongs to the sentencing judge. If it charges a magazine, the counts can both stand.

Know what the lowest lawful § 10(m) sentence is. After DaSilva and Psikarakis, a sentence of one year to one year and one day is not lawful for someone without an FID card, and a judge's below-floor sentence can be revised upward on the Commonwealth's timely motion.

And find out whether the client held a valid FID card at the time. It does not defeat the charge, but it changes the sentencing range.

Question 9

The 2024 firearms act changed § 10(m) only by replacing the word "weapon" with "firearm." DaSilva, 105 Mass. App. Ct. at 734 n.3; Psikarakis, 497 Mass. at 307-308. The sentencing structure discussed here predates the act.

If you or someone you represent is facing a § 10(m) or § 10(a) charge, or a sentence that may be unlawful, you can request a meeting through the intake form.

Disclaimer: This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content. If you need legal advice, consult an attorney about your specific situation. Full disclaimer.