Firearms Licensing

Your FID Card Was Denied, Suspended or Revoked: How the Process Works in Massachusetts

← Back to Blog

A Firearm Identification (FID) card is not handled the same way as a License to Carry. If your police chief believes you are unsuitable, the chief cannot simply deny or revoke your card. The chief has to file a petition in the District Court, and if the court does not rule within 90 days, the law enters a judgment that you are suitable. If the chief instead says you are a prohibited person, the denial is immediate, and it is up to you to petition the District Court within 90 days.

This post covers the process under the current statute, G.L. c. 140, § 121F, as inserted by St. 2024, c. 135, § 32. If you are still sorting out what an FID card is and what it allows, start with my post on Massachusetts FID card basics. If your situation involves a License to Carry, the process is different, and my LTC appeal series covers it.

Is an FID denial handled the same way as an LTC denial?

No. For a License to Carry, the chief decides, and you appeal. For an FID card, the answer depends on the reason the chief gives.

The statute sorts denials into two kinds. A prohibited person is someone who falls into one of the categories listed in § 121F(j), such as certain convictions, certain mental health commitments, or a current abuse prevention or harassment prevention order. A denial on that basis is mandatory. An unsuitability determination is different. It is a judgment that, based on reliable, articulable and credible information about your own behavior, you may create a risk to public safety or a risk of danger to yourself or others. For an FID card, the chief is not allowed to make that judgment alone.

What happens if the chief thinks I am unsuitable for an FID card?

Section 121F(l) says that for an FID application or renewal, the licensing authority "shall not have the authority to deny an application on the grounds of unsuitability." Instead, the chief may file a petition asking the District Court to deny it. The process runs like this:

StepWhat the statute requires
The petitionThe chief files a petition in the District Court, based on a written statement of the reasons for finding you unsuitable, and gives you a copy of the petition and the statement when it is filed.
Your applicationThe petition puts your application on hold while the court decides.
The hearingThe court must hold a hearing within 90 days of receiving the petition and enter a judgment on suitability.
The standardA finding of unsuitability must rest on a preponderance of the evidence that there is reliable, articulable and credible information about your behavior showing that risk.
If the court finds you unsuitableThe court must tell you in writing the specific reasons.
If the court does not rule in timeIf no judgment of unsuitability is entered within 90 days of the petition, a judgment that you are suitable is entered automatically.

The practical point is that the chief, not you, has to start the court case and put the reasons in writing. The written statement is the document to study first, because it defines what the hearing is about.

Construing the earlier version of this procedure, the Appeals Court said the statute “reserves to the District Court the decision whether the licensing authority has met its burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that the applicant is unsuitable.” Town of Plymouth v. Power, 97 Mass. App. Ct. 532, 533 (2020). The District Court decides the question itself rather than reviewing the chief’s judgment for arbitrariness, id. at 537-538, and a late petition by the chief does not make the card issue automatically, id. at 536-537. Section 121F(l) carries that procedure forward in similar terms; no appellate court has yet applied the current version.

What if the chief wants to suspend or revoke an FID card I already hold?

For unsuitability, the same rule applies: the chief has to go to court. Under § 121F(u)(1), the chief files a petition in the District Court to suspend or revoke the card. Filing the petition suspends or revokes the card while the court decides. The court must then make a determination of "sufficient evidence of unsuitability" within 15 days of the filing, and after that the procedures and standards of subsection (l) apply.

If the chief says you have become a prohibited person, for example because a qualifying order or conviction has entered, the revocation or suspension is mandatory and no court petition by the chief is required. Your remedy is the petition described in the next section. Under § 121F(u)(2), any suspension or revocation must be in writing and state the reasons, and a pending court case does not stay it.

What if the denial says I am a prohibited person?

A denial, suspension or revocation on prohibited-person grounds can be challenged by a petition for judicial review in the District Court under § 121F(v)(2). Three details matter:

The deadline. You must file within 90 days after you receive notice of the denial, suspension or revocation. If the chief never responds to your application at all, a separate 90-day period runs from the end of the time the chief had to respond. Under § 121F(a), that response time is 40 days from receipt of a completed application.

The exception. The petition is not available if "a hearing has previously been held" under §§ 131S or 131T (extreme risk protection orders), chapter 209A or chapter 258E. If one of those hearings already took place, the route is different and needs individual advice.

The court. You file in the District Court for the city or town where you applied or where the card was issued.

The court may order the card issued or reinstated only if it finds both that there was "no reasonable ground" for the denial, suspension or revocation and that you are not prohibited by law from holding the card (§ 121F(v)(3)). Under current appellate decisions, the person bringing the petition carries the burden of making that showing. Chief of Police of Worcester v. Holden, 470 Mass. 845, 862 (2015); Chief of Police of Taunton v. Caras, 95 Mass. App. Ct. 182, 185 (2019); Guinane v. Chief of Police of Manchester-by-the-Sea, 106 Mass. App. Ct. 412, 416 (2026). The judge holds a hearing and is not limited to the chief's file, but does not substitute a personal view for the chief's.

Does an old conviction disqualify me from an FID card forever?

Not always. Three categories of conviction in § 121F(j)(i) (clauses (B), (D) and (E): certain misdemeanors punishable by more than two years, certain firearms offenses, and drug offenses) disqualify an FID applicant only for 5 years after the conviction or release from confinement, probation or parole, whichever is later. That five-year limit applies to FID cards, not to Licenses to Carry.

Two cautions. First, state law is not the only law. Federal law has its own disqualifications, and the statute does not allow a card to issue unless the State Police certify that issuing it would not violate state or federal law. The Appeals Court has noted that an OUI conviction can be a federal disqualifier as well as a state one. Commonwealth v. Erler, 106 Mass. App. Ct. 149, 151-152 (2025). Passing the five-year mark does not by itself guarantee eligibility.

Second, there is a separate path for some older convictions. Under G.L. c. 140, § 130B, a person whose disqualifying offense was punishable by two and a half years or less, other than an assault or battery on a family or household member, may petition the Firearm Licensing Review Board after five years. The petitioner must prove suitability by clear and convincing evidence, and relief requires a two-thirds vote of the board, which may grant it only if that conviction, arising out of a single incident, is the only disqualifier. That path is available for FID cards and Licenses to Carry alike.

Who can apply for an FID card?

Under § 129B(a), FID cards are for Massachusetts residents. Applicants 18 and older apply on their own. Applicants 15 to 17 need a parent or guardian's certificate of permission, and a 14-year-old may apply but will not receive the card until turning 15. Nonresidents cannot get a Massachusetts FID card; rules for nonresidents carrying rifles and shotguns in Massachusetts are in § 129C.

The licensing authority must decide a completed application within 40 days and give the reasons for a denial in writing (§ 121F(a)). That written notice is the start of your 90-day clock if the denial rests on prohibited-person grounds, so keep it and note the date you received it.

What should I do first?

Identify which kind of decision you have. If the chief has filed a court petition claiming you are unsuitable, you are a respondent in a case with a short statutory timetable, and the written statement of reasons is the document to answer. If you received a denial or revocation letter citing a prohibited-person category, the 90-day petition deadline is running from the day you received it. Either way, the facts and records you gather now are what the court will see.

Currency note: This post describes the law as amended by St. 2024, c. 135, effective October 2, 2024. Question 9 on the November 3, 2026 ballot asks voters whether to keep that act. I will update this post after the vote.

If you have received an FID denial, a revocation letter, or a court petition from your licensing authority, you can request a meeting through the intake form.

Disclaimer: This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content. If you need legal advice, consult an attorney about your specific situation. Full disclaimer.