Firearms Law

SJC Upholds the Under-21 License to Carry Rule in Commonwealth v. Thomson

Photo: Massachusetts State House by Ajay Suresh, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
← Back to Blog

The Supreme Judicial Court ruled 5-2 that Massachusetts may refuse licenses to carry to 18-to-20-year-olds, and two justices would have sent the case back for more historical evidence before deciding.

On October 20, 2026, the Supreme Judicial Court decided Commonwealth v. Thomson, SJC-13856, which asked whether the state's minimum age for a License to Carry violates the Second Amendment. The court held that it does not. For anyone between 18 and 20 who is charged with carrying a gun without a license, the decision closes one door and leaves another slightly open.

What Happened

In December 2021, a Boston police officer stopped a car for running a red light. Mikai Thomson, then 20 years old, was in the front passenger seat. When the officer asked him to step out, he pushed the officer and ran, and along the way he threw away a loaded nine millimeter handgun. A Boston Municipal Court jury convicted him of assault and battery on a police officer and of carrying a firearm without a license under G.L. c. 269, § 10(a).

Thomson had never applied for a License to Carry. At 20, he could not have received one: Massachusetts has required License to Carry applicants to be at least 21 since the Gun Control Act of 1998. St. 1998, c. 180, § 41; G.L. c. 140, § 131(d). (The 2024 gun law moved the application process to G.L. c. 140, § 121F, but the age requirement remains in § 131(d).) On appeal, he argued that the age requirement itself violates the Second Amendment. The SJC took the case from the Appeals Court on its own initiative.

The Legal Question

Since the United States Supreme Court's decision in New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass'n v. Bruen, 597 U.S. 1 (2022), courts decide Second Amendment cases in two steps. First, does the Second Amendment's text cover the conduct? If it does, the government must show that its law is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.

The SJC had to answer both questions for Massachusetts's under-21 rule. It also had to decide whether Thomson could challenge the rule at all, since he never applied for a license.

Standing: You Usually Have to Apply First

The court reaffirmed that a defendant who wants to challenge the licensing scheme as applied to him generally must have applied for a license and been denied. Thomson had not. The court did leave a door open: it "do[es] not now foreclose" an exception where applying would have been futile, "in an appropriate case on an adequate record." Thomson had not tried to make that showing.

A defendant may still bring a facial challenge, meaning a claim that the law is unconstitutional in every application, without having applied. The court decided Thomson's case on that basis.

The Court's Reasoning

Step one was easy. The court said it "requires no discussion to conclude" that carrying a handgun falls within the Second Amendment's text. It assumed, without deciding, that a 20-year-old is one of "the people" the Amendment protects. That shifted the burden to the Commonwealth.

Step two turned on history. The court described Massachusetts's licensing rules as a graduated system. Children may use firearms only in supervised settings, a teenager can get a Firearms Identification Card at 15 with a parent's certificate, and the age for unsupervised carry is 21. The court called 21 the Legislature's "age of competence," and said the purpose of the scheme is to "limit access to deadly weapons by irresponsible persons" and to protect young people from the consequences of their own immaturity.

For the historical tradition, the court adopted the founding-era research in National Rifle Ass'n v. Bondi, 133 F.4th 1108 (11th Cir. 2025) (en banc), which upheld Florida's ban on gun sales to people under 21. It added Massachusetts sources of its own: colonial and early militia laws, under which parents, masters or the town supplied arms to enrolled minors and commanders supervised their use; and the common law's long treatment of minors as lacking full legal capacity. The court concluded that the modern licensing rules and that history are "closely analogous," and it affirmed the conviction.

The Dissent: Decide Now, or Build a Record First?

Justice Kafker, joined by Justice Wendlandt, agreed that Thomson could bring a facial challenge but would have remanded for expert historical evidence and supplemental briefing before deciding it. He also noted that Bondi involved gun sales, while Thomson was convicted of possession.

The majority answered that whether today's law matches the historical tradition is "a legal one," "comfortably within our bailiwick" to decide on the record before it.

What This Means

For 18-to-20-year-olds charged under § 10(a): a facial Second Amendment challenge to the under-21 rule is now foreclosed in Massachusetts unless the United States Supreme Court says otherwise. Courts elsewhere have split on age restrictions, and the Supreme Court has so far declined to take up the question, so that may not happen soon.

As-applied challenges are not dead, but they require groundwork. The cleanest path is an actual application and denial. A defendant who did not apply must be prepared to prove that applying would have been futile, with a real record, not an assumption.

Raise it in the trial court. Thomson did not raise the issue at trial, so the SJC reviewed it only for a substantial risk of a miscarriage of justice, and it refused to send the case back to build a historical record that neither side had asked for. The lesson for defense counsel is to raise a Second Amendment defense early and support it with evidence, including expert historical evidence where it matters, before the case reaches the appellate courts.

Expect the court to do its own research. In Second Amendment cases, the SJC has now made clear it will look beyond what the parties brief.

Resources

Disclaimer: This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content. If you need legal advice, consult an attorney about your specific situation. Full disclaimer.